|
Contact Us | Tell-a-Friend | Archives | Permalink | Subscribe to Feed
|
Playing The Fear Card Again
In late 2005, President Bush acknowledged
that his administration had authorized a secret warrantless domestic
surveillance program. The administration's program operated
in violation of the Constitution's
Fourth Amendment restriction against "unreasonable searches"
without a warrant. It also violated of
federal law -- the
Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) -- which makes it a
crime to conduct electronic surveillance, except as "authorized
by and conducted pursuant to a search warrant or court order." For
the past two years, Congress has sought to rein in Bush's reckless
disregard of the Constitution and the law. In early Aug. 2007, Congress
unwisely passed a temporary expansion of FISA, called the Protect
America Act (PAA), which provided
virtually unchecked power to the administration to spy on American
communications without warrants. Tomorrow, the unnecessary
and dangerous powers given to the administration by Congress six
months ago are set to expire. Now, as Congress and the administration
wrangle over how to resolve their differences on surveillance
legislation, Bush is reacting by spouting fear.
Yesterday, he warned Congress that if it does not greatly expand the
president's powers to spy, then the country faces terror strikes
that would make 9/11 "pale
by comparison."
Rep. Ted Poe (R-TX) added that Congress's unwillingness to cater to
Bush's demands means that "there is probably
joy throughout the terrorist cells
throughout the world."
LET IT EXPIRE: Intelligence
experts concede that very
little will
actually change Saturday if the PAA is allowed
to expire.
"Expiration of the current Protect America Act would
not mean an immediate end to wiretapping." Every spying
authorization already entered under the law "can remain in effect for 12
months from the date it was issued." As Richard Clarke, Bush's own
former counterterrorism adviser, wrote
recently in the Philadelphia Inquirer, "Let me be clear: Our ability to
track and monitor terrorists overseas
would
not cease should the Protect America Act expire. If this were
true, the president would not threaten to terminate any temporary
extension with his veto pen. All surveillance currently occurring would
continue even after
legislative provisions lapsed because authorizations issued under the
act are in effect up to a full year." Moreover, new authorizations
would be permitted through the underlying FISA law, which
permits emergency surveillance of terrorists as long as a warrant is
applied for within 72
hours. Kate Martin,
Director of the Center for National Security Studies, added,
"If the government learns of new individuals apparently
plotting
terrorist activities, it can immediately surveil such individuals
--
whether they are here or calling here from abroad -- by obtaining a
FISA
court order." Lastly, the administration can continue to use its
authority under Executive Order 12333 to conduct surveillance
abroad of any known or suspected terrorist.
NO FEAR: President Franklin
Roosevelt's cautionary admonition that "the only thing we have to fear is fear
itself" remains particularly instructive in the current debate over
surveillance. "For this president, fear
is an easier political tactic than compromise," wrote Clarke. "With
FISA, he is attempting to rattle Congress into hastily
expanding
his own executive powers at the expense of civil liberties and
constitutional protections." Earlier this week, Bush and his
conservative allies in Congress thwarted
the passage of a 21-day extension of the PAA.
House Judiciary Committee Chairman John Conyers (D-MI) explained, "The
President and House Republicans cannot have it both ways,
simultaneously arguing that the PAA is essential to national security
and also engineering the defeat of an extension of it. The consequences
for inaction are their responsibility." In a terse and direct letter to
Bush, House Intelligence Committee Chairman Silvestre Reyes
(D-TX) said, "I, for one, do not intend to back down – not to the
terrorists and
not to anyone, including a President, who wants Americans to cower in
fear. We are a strong nation. We cannot allow ourselves
to be scared into
suspending the Constitution. If we do that, we might as well call
the
terrorists and tell them that they have won."
PUTTING TELEPHONE COMPANIES FIRST:
The biggest sticking point in negotiations between Congress and the
President over surveillance is whether to grant retroactive amnesty to
telecommunications companies that broke the law and cooperated with the
administration's illegal requests.
Caroline Frederickson, director of the American Civil Liberties Union's
legislative office, urged Congress not to "give the phone companies a
'get out of jail free' card. If the
companies really 'did the right thing' as the president said,
then they
have nothing
to fear from going to court." Bush has declared he will veto any
bill that does not include retroactive immunity. Sen. Edward
Kennedy (D-MA) pointed out that "the president
has said that American lives will be sacrificed if Congress does not
change FISA. But he has also said that he will veto any FISA
bill that does not grant retroactive immunity. ... So if we take the
president at his word, he's willing
to let Americans die to protect the
phone companies."
|
|
|
|
"Some of the world's top companies vowed Friday to step up their efforts to cut greenhouse gas emissions, saying governments were failing to show sufficient leadership in the fight against global warming."
PENNSYLVANIA:
Sign up here
for a National Green Jobs Conference in Pittsburgh in March.
FLORIDA:
Only 22 percent of Florida parents "want public schools to teach an
evolution-only curriculum."
ENVIRONMENT:
"Dead zones" of marine life off the coasts of Oregon and Washington are
likely tied to global warming.
THINK
PROGRESS: Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice lies to Rep. Robert
Wexler (D-FL) about making false statements before the Iraq war.
VOLUNTEER
VOTERS:
Tennessee state senator claims rape just isn't what it used to be.
BLOG
FOR OUR FUTURE: Debunking 10 right-wing myths about Canadian health
care.
RAW
STORY: Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-CT) excuses waterboarding: "It's not
like we're burning people with hot coals."




