Polling Shows Americans Want Retirement Policy Reform
Americans are deeply worried about their retirement security and are calling on elected officials to take action. In poll after poll, the public has made clear that their ability to afford a comfortable retirement is among their primary concerns and that they believe retirement reform should be a much higher priority in Washington. Unfortunately, outside of Social Security, retirement policy has rarely been a topic of political debate, and in recent years, little has been achieved in the way of implementing real change.
As this review of polling on retirement security shows, however, the time for action is now. Among its most important findings are:
- In the wake of the Great Recession, Americans’ confidence in their ability to save enough for retirement has reached record lows.
- A majority of the public believes the existing retirement system is under stress and requires immediate reform.
- Americans think retirement security is a responsibility to be shared by workers, employers, and the government.
- Support for retirement reform is strong among Democrats, Republicans, and independents alike.
- Americans want to strengthen Social Security and do not want to cut benefits.
- To supplement Social Security, Americans are open to a variety of potential fixes to the current private system, ranging from small alterations to more significant restructuring. The public seems most supportive of approaches that combine elements of 401(k)s and pensions, such as the Secure, Affordable, Flexible, and Efficient, or SAFE, Retirement Plan, developed by the Center for American Progress, or the USA Retirement Funds Plan proposed by Sen. Tom Harkin (D-IA).
Policymakers should listen to their constituents and begin taking action to improve all parts of the three-legged stool of retirement—Social Security, workplace retirement plans, and private savings. Without such changes, the public’s anxiety over retirement may only worsen; but more importantly, an ever-increasing number of Americans may find themselves approaching the end of their working years unprepared for what lies ahead.
High levels of public concern
For decades, polls have shown that Americans are worried about retirement—concerns that have increased significantly in recent years, especially since the Great Recession began. Americans have strong fears about outliving their money and being forced into a lower standard of living when they retire.
Polling in 2013 by the Employee Benefit Research Institute, for example, found that only 13 percent of American workers were very confident that they would have enough money for a comfortable retirement, with 38 percent saying they are somewhat confident, 21 percent not too confident, and 28 percent not at all confident. The percentage of respondents answering not at all confident was the highest in the 23-year history of the survey, and the percentage that was either not too confident or not at all confident remains nearly unchanged from the record-high levels reached in 2011. Furthermore, even when retirement confidence was higher during much of the 1990s and 2000s, only a maximum of 27 percent of workers were ever very confident they would have a comfortable retirement.
Other polls with reasonably long-term trends also show consistent and increasing worries about retirement. A 2013 Gallup poll found that 61 percent of Americans were worried about having enough money for retirement, up by 8 percentage points since 2001. Similarly, Pew polling also shows that concerns about retirement have increased.
Most questions about retirement are geared to capture concerns about maintaining preretirement standards of living in retirement, but questions about other facets of retirement can lead to higher or lower levels of concern. A 2013 poll by the Employee Benefit Research Institute, for example, found that 70 percent of workers were confident that they would have enough money to pay for basic expenses in retirement, while 48 percent were confident that they would be able to pay for medical expenses, and only 37 percent were confident that they would be able to pay for long-term care.
Concerns about retirement cut across demographic groups; Americans of all races and ethnicities have similar levels of concern about maintaining their standard of living in retirement. A 2012 Pew survey found that 39 percent of whites, 37 percent of blacks, and 33 percent of Hispanics were not confident that they would have enough to live on in retirement.
Retirement is a worry for Americans of all ages—though the exact level of concern varies quite a bit by age group. The age group most concerned about retirement varies over time, as Pew research finds, but generally, mid-career workers have the highest level of concern. The youngest Americans, who see retirement as a far-off event, and the oldest, who are well into retirement and have already altered their expectations, have the lowest levels of concern.
Though Americans’ concerns about retirement are clear, it is important to look at the priority Americans give it compared to other economic concerns. Here, the polling data can give conflicting impressions. By some measures, retirement meets or exceeds other issues; but by other measures, it falls well below other issues. This is likely because day-to-day financial pressures often take priority over longer-term worries such as retirement but do not lessen long-term concerns.
When given the opportunity to explain their level of concern about multiple issues, Americans list retirement among their biggest financial worries. A 2013 Gallup poll, for example, found that 61 percent of Americans were very or moderately worried about “not having enough money for retirement.” This concern topped worries about medical costs, paying normal monthly bills, and paying for a child’s college education. A similar question asked in a 2012 Gallup poll found that 57 percent of Americans were worried about outliving their money in retirement, falling behind only fears about the national economy. A 2013 Allstate/National Journal Heartland Monitor poll found that Americans were equally concerned about saving for long-term needs such as retirement as they were with their income not keeping up with expenses.
In contrast, when polls require respondents to give only one answer to the question about their largest financial concern, retirement is not an issue of great importance. A 2013 poll by the Employee Benefit Research Institute, for example, shows that only 2 percent of workers identified saving or planning for retirement as “the most pressing issue facing most Americans today.” The top responses in the poll were job uncertainty at 30 percent, making ends meet at 12 percent, and health insurance and medical expenses at 9 percent.12 Furthermore, Gallup found in an April 2012 poll that only 4 percent of respondents listed retirement savings as the most important financial problem facing their family today. The concerns about low incomes and high health care costs once again topped the poll.
This tension in the polling data suggests that while Americans are deeply concerned about retirement, they will prioritize more immediate problems when forced to make that decision.
The public wants action and are open to many policy solutions
Given their high level of concern, it is not surprising that Americans want policymakers to take steps to improve retirement security.
According to a 2013 poll from the National Institute on Retirement Security, 89 percent of Americans agree that “the retirement system in this country is under stress and needs to be reformed.” The support for this position is fairly strong, as 62 percent of respondents strongly agreed with that statement. The same poll found that 86 percent of Americans “strongly agree” or “somewhat agree”that “leaders in Washington need to give a higher priority to ensuring more Americans can have a secure retirement.”
Support for retirement policy reform also cuts across political party lines. According to an AARP poll, 67 percent of Republicans, 75 percent of independents, and 88 percent of Democrats say that Congress and the president should place a high priority on helping people save for retirement, and other polls have similar findings.
What kinds of policy reform the public prefers, however, is a more open question.
Social Security is among the programs Americans care most deeply about repairing. Approximately 86 percent of American households with residents ages 65 and older receive Social Security benefits, and 61 percent of retirees say they depend on the program as a major source of income, according to a 2013 Gallup poll. Yet while 72 percent of Americans held a favorable view of the program as of 2012—including a majority of Democrats, Republicans, and independents—75 percent of those polled in 2013 said they personally worry either a great deal or fair amount about Social Security. Indeed, 57 percent of respondents in a different poll said they considered funding for Social Security to be either in a state of crisis or a serious problem, highlighting the public’s desire for action to save an essential program that they broadly support.
When it comes to how to fix Social Security, Americans have repeatedly indicated a strong preference for protecting benefits, even if it means paying higher taxes. According to a 2012 Associated Press-GfK poll, only 36 percent of respondents preferred cutting benefits as a means of fixing Social Security, while 53 percent preferred tax increases. Polls conducted by the AARP, Gallup, and the National Academy of Social Insurance have all produced similar conclusions.22 The latter even found that when presented with a set of policies that would raise taxes and actually increase benefits, 71 percent of those polled said they would support the plan.
Looking at specific policies, the same 2012 National Academy of Social Insurance’s poll found that 69 percent of respondents would support a gradual increase of Social Security taxes from 6.2 percent to 7.2 percent, and 68 percent would support a gradual elimination of the cap on income subject to Social Security taxes. Other polls also show strong support for eliminating the taxable income cap, including a 2010 Gallup poll that found that 67 percent of those surveyed felt that such a change would be a good idea. At the same time, Americans are generally opposed to specific benefit cuts such as reductions in cost of living adjustments or means-testing benefits, and according to a recent Pew poll, 56 percent also oppose increasing the age at which one can begin receiving benefits.
When asked about private retirement plans, Americans have positive opinions of existing plan options but are nevertheless supportive of significant reforms that would improve retirement preparedness.
First, when looking at the public’s opinions of the current private plan landscape, polls have shown that they generally have positive feelings toward both defined-benefit and defined-contribution plans. According to a 2009 poll by the National Institute on Retirement Security, 86 percent of the public has a favorable view of defined-benefit pensions, and 85 percent have a favorable view of 401(k) plans.
Though Americans may have favorable views of current programs, they are still very supportive of several reform proposals. In fact, they support plans that run the gamut of the policy spectrum, from small tweaks at the edges of the private system to dramatic changes that would fundamentally overhaul workplace retirement plans.
A large majority of Americans, for example, support a proposal to increase access to individual savings plans; 79 percent said they would support automatic Individual Retirement Accounts, or IRAs, according to a 2009 Hart Research Associates survey. The public, however, also expresses support for more dramatic changes, with 79 percent of Americans in support of requiring companies to provide a pension plan with a guaranteed retirement income.
Americans are also supportive of proposals to create new retirement plans that are similar to traditional pensions but are more flexible and combine elements of traditional pensions with 401(k) style plans—proposals that are very similar to the Center for American Progress’s SAFE Retirement Plan and the USA Retirement Funds Plan from Sen. Tom Harkin (D-IA). Seventy-five percent of Americans think that a “new privately run, universal, portable pension system” is a “very good” or “pretty good” idea. When given a description of a new hybrid-style retirement plan that combines elements of a traditional pension with elements of a 401(k) plan, 81 percent of Americans are “very likely” or “somewhat likely” to “participate in this plan if it were available.”
When asked about specific aspects of a hypothetical retirement plan, a majority of Americans find plan portability and matching contributions from employers “extremely desirable,” while 45 percent think the same about “receiving a regular monthly check that cannot be outlived.” The strong support for these features is almost double the strong support for a feature that would allow the saver to make investment decisions, which was found extremely desirable by only 24 percent of respondents. These answers paint a picture of Americans who would prefer a retirement plan that reduces decision making and research for them and instead delegates those responsibilities to the retirement fund.
In short, Americans are in favor of a wide range of retirement policy reforms from small additions to more significant restructuring of the current system, as long as they think it will increase retirement quality. While studies have shown that the public continues to have a limited understanding of the intricacies of the current retirement system, this has not lessened their support for change and, if anything, speaks to the need for us to finally have a national conversation on retirement policy.
There are certainly limits to how much change the American public would support, but despite their generally more individualistic views compared to their peers in places such as Western Europe, polls still indicate that Americans as a whole view the provision of retirement security as a responsibility to be split among workers, employers, and the government.
A survey by the John J. Heldrich Center for Workforce Development at Rutgers University for example, found that while 39 percent of those surveyed said workers should be primarily responsible for preparing for retirement, 25 percent said employers, 18 percent answered government, and 17 percent volunteered that all three should be responsible. Additional surveys by AARP and Hart Research Associates also suggest that a division of responsibility between employers, the government, and individuals is the public’s preference.
As all of these polls make clear, Americans are deeply concerned about retirement, and their worries are only increasing. Many fear that they will not have enough money to support themselves or their families in retirement, and a substantial majority would welcome a variety of proposals geared toward helping them do just that.
While there is still a great deal to be learned about the precise nature of the public’s preferences, the data are clear that Americans want retirement policy reform. Now is the time for policymakers to listen and to take up the challenge, so that Americans—instead of approaching it with fear—can look forward to retirement.
David Madland is Director of the American Worker Project at the Center for American Progress Action Fund. Keith Miller is a Research Assistant with the American Worker Project.
The positions of American Progress, and our policy experts, are independent, and the findings and conclusions presented are those of American Progress alone. A full list of supporters is available here. American Progress would like to acknowledge the many generous supporters who make our work possible.
Senior Fellow; Senior Adviser, American Worker Project
Senior Research Associate