The Romney Rule

Time to Repeal the Romney Rule

You’ve heard of the Buffett Rule proposed by President Obama — the simple idea that no millionaire should be able to use tax loopholes to cheat the system and pay a lower tax rate than hardworking middle class Americans.  All President Obama is proposing is that millionaires and billionaires pay at least the same rate as middle class Americans.

The Romney Rule is the opposite — the fact that Mitt Romney thinks millionaires like him who make money off their wealth are entitled to pay a lower tax rate than middle class Americans who earn their money from wages.

Romney’s Response? A Fake Middle Class Tax Cut

In response to criticism he faced today over the Romney Rule, Romney’s Communications Director Gail Gitcho told Politico:

Mitt Romney has a tax plan that cuts taxes for the middle class.

The only problem with that? It’s just not really true.

ThinkProgress’ Pat Garofalo took a closer look at Romney’s so-called middle class tax cut and found that it just doesn’t add up:

Romney may think he focused his tax cut on the middle-class, but according to a ThinkProgress analysis of Tax Policy Center data, nearly three-fourths of households that make $200,000 or less annually would get literally nothing from Romney’s tax cut, due to the simple fact that most of those households have no capital gains income

To be exact, 73.9 percent of the households upon which Romney “focused” his tax cut will see zero benefit from it. The table below shows how few households in each income bracket would be affected by Romney’s cut:

For families making between $40,000 and $50,000 annually, Romney’s tax cut comes out to a whopping $216 per year.

Meanwhile, the payroll tax cut enacted by the Obama administration in 2011, which Romney derided as a “temporary little Band-Aid,” gave those same households a tax cut of $800 to $1,000.

Fast Facts About Mitt Romney & Taxes


IN ONE PICTURE: Mitt Romney thinks he and his millionaire buddies should be able to use tax loopholes to cheat the system and pay a lower tax rate than hardworking middle class Americans.

Evening Brief: Important Stories That You May Have Missed

Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) single-handedly discredits the Senate’s broken rules.

How the NRA plans to bring countless numbers of concealed firearms to a community near you.

Former Libyan leader Muammar Qaddafi left behind a trove of files of photographs, but the greatest insights into Qaddafi’s personality and rise to power might be found in the Qaddafi family’s private photo albums.

Republican presidential frontrunner Herman Cain told CNN’s Piers Morgan that race is different than sexual orientation because it “doesn’t wash off.”

Rick Santorum (R-PA) was quick to defend Ronald Reagan’s willingness to exchange weapons for hostages with Iran but, a day later, in a Fox New appearance, Santorum contradicted himself, saying, “[The Iranian government] will not and cannot be negotiated with. They are radical Islamists. They are theocrats.”

In defense of Rachel Maddow.

The regulation that could determine the future of health care.

Climate change didn’t “go;” it was pushed.

The feminism of the iPhone 4s’ Siri.

The positions of American Progress, and our policy experts, are independent, and the findings and conclusions presented are those of American Progress alone. A full list of supporters is available here. American Progress would like to acknowledge the many generous supporters who make our work possible.


Advocacy Team